The law will never be able to adequately define the difference between right and wrong/legal and illegal/valuable and worthless within art appropriation. How can something determined by opinion be static? A good set of laws should be able to be applied fairly to each situation concerning the practice. Of course there are parts of fair use law that reference limits of appropriated pieces in a derivative art work – using percentages – but this measurable element is merely one aspect of fair use. It seems that the most serious determiner used in court cases concerning art appropriation is the presence of a message within the work – usually a result of transforming the original. We’ve seen that artists on trial who cannot really express an adequate message (a basic worthwhile idea will usually suffice) for their work are usually punished. But how can an “adequate message” really be defined? Unless one judge with unwavering criteria for the existence of an adequate message is employed in every case, we’ll never get a consistent view. And we all know that court rulings set precedent, clarifying the law.
Many artists really have an unfair advantage when it comes to protecting their work through legal battles. A lot of issues would never come to light if it weren’t for all the resources behind some of the biggest artists, who sometimes seem to abuse their legal power – threatening everyone in sight, even if their claims are less than sturdy. Actually, the vast majority of artists who have had their work appropriated unfairly are unlikely to have the funds to take legal action, so artists who have appropriated unfairly are unlikely to see any kind of lawsuit. Both situations seem wildly unjust.
I think most people who enjoy art agree that appropriation can be a valuable method, as long as the artist adheres to common ethics and transforms an original work with a purpose. Combined with all these matters of opinion, technology’s role is substantial – the internet allows art appropriation to spread like wildfire, programs available for easy editing are widespread, and the law simply cannot keep up. Fstoppers article, “The Stolen Scream”, is a shocking account of the speed at which appropriation can thrust an image around the globe. Noam Galai used Flickr to post a few particularly compelling pictures of himself screaming online – two years later, a friend showed him a work she found which was essentially an appropriation of his image. Now, five years later, works using and profiting from his image have shown up in thousands of places all over the world. Galai has absolutely no control over his photographs – he’s tried to contact those who use them illegally, but to no substantial outcome. Galai maintains that he is flattered by the appropriation, but has a problem with it once others profit off of his work. I recommend watching the video, as it really illustrates the way in which appropriation can spin out of control through the Internet. It would be impossible to follow up on all of these cases stemming from one person – how can we attempt to regulate every instance of appropriation? There really is no stopping it, and it is quite unfair that (usually) only those who are already successful have the time and money to do something about it.
Aren’t derivative works a bit more credible and worth looking at since they build upon others’ established ideas? Appropriation artists who build upon known works are inserting themselves into the realm of acclaimed art, which, I suppose, is also one of the effects that those against appropriation balk at. I understand that artists would like to protect their ideas, but isn’t good art supposed to invoke some kind of reaction?


